Why can’t Carnelian and Amethyst be together? 7 Reasons

Jorge Silva
Why can't Carnelian and Amethyst be together? 7 Reasons

Why can’t we join Carnelian and Amethyst? These 2 crystals have different densities, so they would constantly be sinking or floating in the same body of water.

They have different hardness so that one would scratch the other very quickly.

The crystals have different Mohs scale ratings, so they would be challenging to set next to each other without one stone looking much nicer than the other.

They have different colors, so they clash horribly if worn together as jewelry.

These 2 crystals are a variety of quartz crystals, but their chemical compositions are quite different.

The healing properties of these stones are not compatible at all Carnelian is used for grounding and protection.

In contrast, Amethyst is used for spiritual development and peace- a person wearing these stones will experience the opposite effects from what they need! 

Why shouldn’t we join some crystals?


Both stones are very hard, so they can scratch each other. Carnelian is a bit more fragile than amethyst, so it’s more likely to break if they’re together.

The colors of the two stones can clash, making them less visually appealing together.

Each stone has different energies, which can cancel each other out or create an imbalance.

Amethyst emits higher levels of energy that could make Carnelian feel depleted, while Carnelian emits lower levels of energy that could make Amethyst feel depleted.

When one stone starts to fade or decompose due to heat, humidity, UV light, and natural aging processes, the other stone will quickly follow suit.

Some people believe that combining any crystal with another crystal of a different type creates magical incompatibility.

Can we use Carnelian and Amethyst combination? 


Both stones are beautiful and can be used to make stunning jewelry, but they don’t go well together. Carnelian is a warm stone, while amethyst is an excellent stone.

  • Carnelian is an energizing stone, while amethyst is a calming stone;

  • Carnelian is a fiery stone, while amethyst is a serene stone;

  • Amethyst is a passive stone, while carnelian is an active stone;

  • Carnelian represents the element of fire, while amethyst represents the element of water.

Overall, these two stones don’t complement each other well and are better used separately in different jewelry pieces.

There are some exceptions where carnelian and amethyst might look good together – like if carnelian was paired with red coral or garnet – because those combinations create a nice contrast that highlights both stones’ best qualities.

For example, carnelian looks especially lovely when paired with any deep red gemstone like garnet or bloodstone since those colors evoke passion and love, respectively.

But otherwise, carnelian should never be combined with amethyst for long-term wear or regular use.

Why can’t Carnelian and Amethyst be together?

Why can't Carnelian and Amethyst be together?

Specific stones and crystals work well when worn with others or independently. However, there are a few who just don’t get along!

In this blog article, I’ll discuss why Carnelian and Amethyst stones shouldn’t be worn together – not even in jewelry!

This information can help you choose the best crystals for your needs and avoid conflict between rocks in your collection of healing stones and other gems.

Here are seven reasons why Carnelian stone and Amethyst stone shouldn’t be worn together

1) Metaphysical properties

Carnelian is a grounding stone that can anchor us in the present moment. It helps restore vitality and motivation and can give us courage when needed.

Amethyst is an uplifting gemstone that encourages empathy and love.

While these two stones are often used together for their contrasting properties, they should not be kept with each other because of their malicious purposes: one stone to ground you while the other stone lifts you.

2) Meaning

  • Carnelian is a rock, while amethyst is a mineral.

  • They have different hardness levels, which means they can scratch each other.

  • They have different chemical compositions, so they can react with each other when heated or exposed to light.

  • They have different Mohs Scale ratings, which means one is more complex than the other and can scratch it. 5. They have different densities, so if you wear them together as jewelry, one might fall off before the other. The appearance of these stones is very similar, but they have different colors: Carnelian is orange-brown while amethyst ranges from purple to lilac. Amethyst has inclusions, while carnelian doesn’t. 

  • Carnelian may be radioactive, while amethyst is not. 

3) Astrological compatibility

As two of the most popular stones in the crystal world, it’s no surprise that people often ask if carnelian stone and amethyst stone are compatible.

Unfortunately, the answer is no.

One reason for this is because they have different zodiac signs: the carnelian stone is a Leo sign while the amethyst stone is a Virgo sign.

Furthermore, both stones have masculine energies and share fire as their common element, which means they will fight against each other rather than help each other grow stronger.

Finally, both are highly protective stones with defensive properties (carnelian more so), meaning they will clash with one another rather than complement one another.

4) Habits

Carnelian stone is associated with the root chakra, which is all about grounding and security.

On the other hand, the Amethyst stone is related to the crown chakra, which is all about spirituality and connection to the higher self.

These two stones represent entirely different energies, so it’s no surprise they wouldn’t work well together.

Amethyst stone also brings a calming effect, while Carnelian stone brings more of a refreshing or stimulating effect.

It might seem like they’re both coming from the same place, but their products are much different from each other.

5) Psychological differences

Carnelian stone is associated with the lower chakras, while the amethyst stone is associated with the higher chakras.

This can create a sense of imbalance, as the two stones pull in opposite directions. They might even react negatively to each other!

  • Different strengths: The strength of the carnelian stone may overpower the weaker amethyst stone, leaving it feeling intimidated.

  • Reactions: These stones can either have an entirely positive or entirely adverse reaction.

  • Weight: Carnelian is much heavier than amethyst; this difference may make both stones feel uncomfortable when they’re near each other.

6) Practicality

Carnelian stone is typically red or orange, while the amethyst stone is purple. This can clash aesthetically.

The two rocks have different densities, making them difficult to set side-by-side in jewelry or other decorative items.

Carnelian stone is more complex than amethyst stone, so it can scratch or chip the softer stone if they’re placed together without proper protection.

If you want to clean both stones simultaneously, you’ll need to use safe cleaning products for both types of rocks.

Carnelian stone is more reactive with chemicals and moisture than amethyst stone, meaning it’s more likely to corrode or change color when exposed to air pollution, high humidity levels, lotions, perfumes, etc.

Carnelian stone has an average hardness of 7 on the Mohs scale (where ten is the hardest), while amethyst stone has a moderate hardness of 7.5 on the Mohs scale.

So, if your carnelian stone becomes scratched or chipped, it may be impossible to buff out those scratches as you could do with softer amethyst stones.

7) Spiritual differences

Carnelian is about grounding and centering oneself, while amethyst is about opening up to spirituality and intuition.

They’re two very different energies that can cancel each other out. You’ll want one or the other, but not both in the same space.

You also want to be careful of layering them too much together because you don’t want one’s energy overpowered by the other.

Amethyst has been known to be a calming stone, so if you put it near your bed, it will help with sleep patterns.

But when there are more intense colors like yellows or pinks around then, they will counteract this calming effect.

It would be better to have an amethyst necklace instead. There are also negative aspects that come with amethyst, such as its connection to psychic abilities and communicating with spirits on the other side, which may be hard for some people.

It may make their headaches worse or exacerbate their conditions.

The spiritual properties of amethyst stones may not be suitable for everyone who does not want to open themselves up spiritually or even just energetically due to health reasons.

Can I use Carnelian with other crystals?


Carnelian is an excellent crystal to use on its own or in combination with other crystals. It has been said that they should not be used together with amethyst because they are opposites, which may disrupt the energy balance.

This doesn’t make sense as I feel there is nothing wrong with using these two stones together.

As long as you follow some basic rules for combining stones, such as placing them at opposite ends of your workspace, you will be able to enjoy the benefits of both stones without any negative consequences.

Carnelian can be used with other crystals, but when it comes to the more energetic stones like amethyst, it is often recommended that they not be combined.

However, according to my understanding, it does not matter if you combine these two as long as you follow some basic rules (such as keeping them separated).

Can I use Amethyst with other crystals?


Yes, but use it sparingly.

Amethyst is a mighty stone, so it should be used in moderation to avoid overloading your energy field.

You can combine crystals with amethyst: clear quartz, black tourmaline, Angelite, danburite, citrine, rose quartz, or iolite.

The best stones for bringing out the purple hue of amethyst are bloodstone, labradorite, hematite, or black onyx.

Avoid combining green stones like jade, emeralds, and peridots with an amethyst necklace because they will cancel each other out! 

Final Words

Both stones are very different in their properties and uses. Carnelian is a grounding stone, while amethyst is a spiritual stone.

They have different energies that can conflict with each other. Wearing them together can create an imbalance in your energy field.

It’s best to separate these two stones to avoid adverse effects on your health and well-being. Some people believe that the colors of the rocks clash against one another, which could be considered unappealing.

The qualities of both stones are strong enough on their own without being combined, so it doesn’t make sense to wear them at the same time anyways!

Amazing articles:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts